Reindeer Cookies

There’s nothing like reindeer cookies to get you in the holiday spirit, especially when paired with a mug of hot cocoa and the sounds of Christmas carols. The best thing about these cookies (other than how adorable they are) is that they’re no-bake and fun to put together, so everyone can pitch in. All it takes is a few minutes of assembling ingredients and decorating, and you’ve got a batch of festive cookies ready to enjoy.

Ingredients for Reindeer Cookies

Sofia Felguerez for Taste of Home

• Dark chocolate candy coating: You could also replace the chocolate candy coating with icing if you’d prefer.
• Nutter Butter cookies: Nutter Butters are great to use here because they look like reindeer heads once you’ve decorated them.
• Miniature marshmallows: Cut the marshmallows into halves to use for the eyes.
• Decorating icing: The icing draws out the reindeer features. If you don’t have decorating icing, you could decorate using brown M&M’s for the eyes and red M&M’s for the nose (leaving out the marshmallows).
• M&M’s or Red Hots: Make sure to gently press these on (face down, so you don’t see the logo) so you don’t break the cookie.
• Miniature pretzels: Place the pretzels into the candy coating or frosting so they stay put.

Directions

Step 1: Dip the cookies in chocolate

Sofia Felguerez for Taste of Home

In a microwave, melt the candy coating and stir until smooth. Dip each cookie in chocolate; allow the excess to drip off. Place on waxed paper.

Step 2: Decorate the tops

Sofia Felguerez for Taste of Home

Attach two marshmallow halves onto the cookies for eyes; add decorating icing for the pupils and a mouth. Add an M&M or Red Hot for the nose. Attach pretzels or pretzel pieces for antlers. Let stand until set.

Sofia Felguerez for Taste of Home

Reindeer Cookie Variations

• Ramp up the peanut butter: Instead of candy coating or frosting, coat the cookies in peanut butter.
• Find different ways to decorate: Feel free to get creative here. Use other types of candy or frosting, pipe white icing on the antlers or decorate however you see fit.

How to Store Reindeer Cookies

Reindeer Christmas cookies are really best enjoyed as soon as you make them, but you can store them in an airtight container in the fridge for a few days if you’d like.

Can I freeze reindeer cookies?

No, we wouldn’t recommend freezing these cookies.

Reindeer Cookie Tips

Sofia Felguerez for Taste of Home

Can I use other types of cookies for this recipe?

You could, but Nutter Butters work well for this recipe because they resemble a reindeer head.

Can I bake cookies to use for this recipe?

Yes, you could bake your own Nutter Butters to use here.

Is there a vegan version of reindeer cookies?

Yes. Make your own (vegan) Nutter Butters using peanut butter, almond flour and maple syrup, then use dairy-free chocolate candy coating and classic Skittles instead of M&M’s.